How much resistance is enough? Should patients train to failure? Does strengthening require a gym?
These are familiar questions in physiotherapy. We prescribe resistance exercise regularly, but the reasoning behind our choices can become blurred by habit, competing recommendations and the search for an ideal programme.
The recenty published 2026 American College of Sports Medicine (ACSM) position stand offers an opportunity to revisit those decisions.[1]
Its central message is encouraging: many forms of resistance training work, with some prescription choices helping to improve particular outcomes.
Before considering those choices, it helps to clarify what resistance training involves—and why it matters.
What is resistance training?
Resistance training involves muscles producing force against resistance to improve qualities such as strength, muscle size, power or muscular endurance.[1]
That resistance might come from dumbbells, machines, resistance bands, water or body weight. Examples include a weighted squat, a band row, a press-up or repeated sit-to-stands that sufficiently challenge the person performing them.
The exercise can involve movement or an isometric contraction, where the muscles produce force without appreciable joint movement.
Resistance training does not require a gym or heavy weights. It does require a meaningful muscular challenge relative to the person’s capacity.
A sit-to-stand may provide substantial resistance for one person while being relatively easy for another. The exercise name alone tells us little about its training stimulus.
How does it differ from other exercise?
Exercise categories overlap, but their main purposes differ:
Resistance training
Challenges muscles to produce force against resistance. Examples include weights, resistance bands, machines and suitably challenging body-weight exercises.
Aerobic exercise
Uses sustained activity to challenge heart and lung fitness. Examples include brisk walking, cycling and swimming.
Mobility and flexibility exercise
Focuses on maintaining or improving movement range. Examples include stretching and controlled joint movements.
Balance training
Challenges control of posture and stability. Examples include standing on one leg or practising movements with a narrower base of support.
Weight-bearing and impact exercise
Weight-bearing activities support body weight against gravity, such as standing and walking. Impact activities, such as hopping and jumping, add forces from landing or ground contact.
A single exercise can address several qualities. A loaded step-up may challenge strength and balance while also increasing breathing rate.
However, weight-bearing exercise is not automatically resistance training. Walking supports body weight, but may provide insufficient muscular challenge to substantially develop strength.
The position stand updates ACSM’s 2009 guidance through an overview of 137 systematic reviews reporting data from more than 30,000 participants. Its systematic search ran to October 2024.[1]
Eligible reviews examined resistance programmes lasting at least six weeks in healthy adults. Outcomes included strength, muscle size, power, endurance and physical performance.
Much of the evidence involved inexperienced trainees. People with defined conditions, including sarcopenia and physical frailty, were outside its intended population.
The findings therefore inform rehabilitation, but do not establish the best treatment for every patient. The sarcopenia and bone-health evidence below comes from additional sources.
Why might resistance training matter clinically?
Supporting function and independence
Compared with no exercise, resistance training improved several functional outcomes, including walking speed, chair-standing performance, balance and timed up-and-go performance.[1]
These are clinically relevant capabilities. Rising from a chair, carrying shopping and negotiating daily activities all require muscular capacity.
However, increasing strength does not guarantee improvement in every activity. Function also depends on balance, coordination, confidence, symptoms and the demands of the task.
For clinicians, this supports measuring both the physical quality being trained and the activity the person wants to improve.
Maintaining muscle health and addressing sarcopenia
Sarcopenia is a muscle disease associated with low strength and reduced muscle quantity or quality. Although common in older age, it can occur earlier.
A 2019 European consensus identified low strength as the basis for probable sarcopenia; low muscle quantity or quality confirms the diagnosis, and poor physical performance indicates severe sarcopenia.[2] It therefore involves more than simply having smaller muscles.
Resistance training can help maintain or improve qualities threatened by ageing and inactivity. For people with established sarcopenia, international clinical guidelines strongly recommend resistance-based physical activity.[3]
This supports its role in muscle-health strategies and treatment, but does not guarantee prevention or reversal. Nutrition, illness and other contributors also require attention.[3]
Resistance training can also support bone health, although this was not an outcome evaluated by the ACSM overview. A systematic review in postmenopausal women found small-to-moderate beneficial effects of dynamic resistance exercise on bone mineral density at the lumbar spine and femoral neck.[4]
These were differences in bone-density change relative to controls: benefit may reflect gains or reduced loss. Effects varied by skeletal site and programme, and the findings should not be assumed to apply equally to every population. Included interventions lasted at least six months, so short rehabilitation programmes should not promise measurable bone-density gains.[4]
Loading matters, but the review could not establish a precise optimal prescription. UK osteoporosis guidance recommends appropriately selected resistance and impact exercise for bone strength, alongside balance activities to reduce falls.[5]
Improved bone density is also different from demonstrated fracture reduction. Bone-density findings alone cannot establish how much a programme reduces fractures; falls and other risk factors matter too. Exercise complements fracture-risk assessment and medical treatment where indicated.[5]
Match the prescription to the goal
The ACSM position stand distinguishes three important outcomes:
Strength concerns force production. In the included evidence, this was usually assessed through a one-repetition maximum—the heaviest load lifted once.
Hypertrophy means increased muscle size.
Power concerns producing force quickly.
Training can improve all three, but the choices that enhance them differ.[1]
For strength, heavier loads have an advantage
Heavier loads, particularly at least 80% of one-repetition maximum, favoured greater strength gains. Other favourable features included two to three sets per exercise, at least two weekly sessions, full-range training and placing priority exercises near the beginning of a session.[1]
These findings concern enhancing gains. Lighter loading can still improve strength particularly in untrained invididuals.
Because strength was usually tested through maximal lifting in the trained movement, the specificity of heavy-lifting practice also matters.
My clinical interpretation is to consider heavier loading when maximal strength is a relevant goal and the person is ready. Findings favouring full-range exercise in healthy adults do not mean patients must immediately train through a painful or restricted range.
For muscle growth, weekly volume matters
Higher weekly volume—around ten or more sets per muscle group—favoured greater hypertrophy.[1]
This is not a threshold below which nothing happens. Lower-volume programmes can help, and the exact optimal dose remains uncertain.
Muscle growth occurred across a broad range of loads. Frequency had no consistent independent advantage when weekly volume was matched, allowing flexibility in how sessions are distributed.
For someone beginning rehabilitation, a manageable volume that can be sustained may be a useful starting point.
For power, movement intention matters
Moderate loads, approximately 30–70% of one-repetition maximum, and relatively low-to-moderate volumes favoured power development. Power training involves intentionally performing the lifting phase quickly and enhanced some functional outcomes compared with conventional training.[1]
This means choosing an appropriate exercise and load, then intending to accelerate. It does not mean uncontrolled movement.
In rehabilitation, introducing faster efforts requires judgement about health, symptoms, confidence and capacity.
Effort matters—but failure is not compulsory
Completing every set to momentary muscular failure was not consistently necessary for strength or hypertrophy benefits.[1]
Failure means reaching the point where another lifting repetition cannot be completed.
The authors suggest that finishing with approximately two to three repetitions in reserve can provide sufficient effort, while acknowledging insufficient evidence for an exact universal target.
This remains an estimate. Asking, “How many more repetitions could you have completed?” can support discussion about challenge, but experience affects the answer.
A light resistance can become demanding over several repetitions taken near to failure. Neither the weight nor repetition count alone fully describes effort.
Keep equipment and progression practical
Bands, home programmes, machines and free weights can all contribute. Machines and free weights showed no consistent overall difference in strength gains.[1]
The paper also does not establish one universal repetition range or rest interval. Rest can be adjusted to support the intended effort and completion of the programme; evidence for its effect on hypertrophy remained insufficient.
Resistance training develops muscular capacity and can support function, muscle health and bone health. Its prescription should reflect the intended outcome and the person undertaking it.
The ACSM position stand supports flexibility alongside purposeful challenge: choose an achievable programme, match it to the goal, and review the person’s response.
View ACSM’s resistance-training infographic
In Part 2, we discuss whether Reformer Pilates exercise can be considered resistance training and what other benefits there might be.
Currier BS, D’Souza AC, Fiatarone Singh MA, et al. American College of Sports Medicine Position Stand. Resistance Training Prescription for Muscle Function, Hypertrophy, and Physical Performance in Healthy Adults: An Overview of Reviews. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise. 2026;58(4):851–872. https://doi.org/10.1249/MSS.0000000000003897
Cruz-Jentoft AJ, Bahat G, Bauer J, et al. Sarcopenia: revised European consensus on definition and diagnosis. Age and Ageing. 2019;48(1):16–31. https://doi.org/10.1093/ageing/afy169
Dent E, Morley JE, Cruz-Jentoft AJ, et al. International Clinical Practice Guidelines for Sarcopenia (ICFSR): Screening, Diagnosis and Management. The Journal of Nutrition, Health & Aging. 2018;22(10):1148–1161. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12603-018-1139-9
Shojaa M, von Stengel S, Kohl M, Schoene D, Kemmler W. Effects of dynamic resistance exercise on bone mineral density in postmenopausal women: a systematic review and meta-analysis with special emphasis on exercise parameters. Osteoporosis International. 2020;31(8):1427–1444. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00198-020-05441-w
Brooke-Wavell K, Skelton DA, Barker KL, et al. Strong, steady and straight: UK consensus statement on physical activity and exercise for osteoporosis. British Journal of Sports Medicine. 2022;56(15):837–846. https://doi.org/10.1136/bjsports-2021-104634
This article provides general education based on evidence and professional interpretation. It does not replace individual assessment or treatment. For personal advice, consult an HCPC-registered physiotherapist or another qualified healthcare professional. Clinicians should apply their own clinical judgement.
Tim Cook © 2026 Physio Principles